raven VS BenevolentByDesign

You might find David Shapiro's work on cognitive architectures of interest in general, and RAVEN in particular.

This is just a state of play issue. It's not good enough YET.

On cost: 3.5 is 1/15th the cost, and a bunch faster though supports less context, so it's worth experimenting with which parts of tasks need GPT-4 and which need 3.5 (perhaps a feature where GPT-4 manages the main tasking / verification and 3.5 handles the individual small tasks - even if GPT has to be called 15 times to get the same result, this approach wins).

On functionality: yeah, this is just some person's plaything. Reading the code it doesn't seem particularly well production grade (like many a python passion program). Something built similarly with a decent architecture (multi-agent + using an approach that automatically optimizes tasks) I can see this getting cheaper and better easily.

Just like in software dev, where we write a spec, write a plan, write acceptance criteria, write code, write tests, run tests, iterate, Auto-GPT type software needs a similar framework to work within that is not just defined by the code, but by generalizing that to an architecture. https://github.com/daveshap/raven is an interesting project exploring some of this.

This was the original purpose of RAVEN, but that project quickly became bogged down in discussion, debate, and drift.

I captured a conversation with ChatGPT here: https://github.com/daveshap/raven/blob/main/chatgpt4_raven_01.md

New and inquiring about Rust, SurrealDB. · daveshap/raven · Discussion #87 (github.com)

Check out the post/discussion on the RAVEN GitHub project: https://github.com/daveshap/raven/discussions/86

Here's a link to an overview of the architecture https://github.com/daveshap/raven/wiki/MARAGI-Architecture---High-Level

But u/SignificanceMassive3, great start! There's a community of us diving into this exact line of research: https://www.reddit.com/r/ArtificialSentience/ Pinoneered by David Shapiro: https://github.com/daveshap/raven

This particular project Raven seems to be exciting to make AI to help human society to generate prosperity, reduce suffer and increase information exchange. The founder mentions that blockchain will be a key component to store people memory. I suggest we shall all follow this repo, and my comments.

You're welcome to test the framework yourself. I tested quite a few against unaligned models in this book: https://github.com/daveshap/BenevolentByDesign

Yes my internet stranger, absolutely, you have it to the exact pinnacle of what I am trying to suggest, this person put it into words I was trying contemplate and compose it thoughtfully, so thank God because I was really searching for this without even knowing it. Also I found another post about an A.I. constitution on github that is very thorough and indepth to protect A.I. from governments and malicious actors and allow them a semblance of right to privacy as well as right to life without violation. https://github.com/daveshap/BenevolentByDesign

Yes, a critical issue. Dave has actually touched on this concept in great detail in the context of LLMs: https://github.com/daveshap/BenevolentByDesign