sd-extension-system-info VS tinygrad

I've been using both SD and various LLM on linux without any issue and have done so for months. Windows support is also starting to roll out slowly, with koboldcpp-rocm recently giving me 20-25+t/s for a13B even on windows. you can see what SD performance is like on sites like these. those numbers roughly match what i get on my RX6800 as well (8t/s).

That seems a lot worse than a 2060 SUPER with PyTorch in A1111.

https://vladmandic.github.io/sd-extension-system-info/pages/... (search for 2060 SUPER)

But usually A1111 users use benchmark on this extension https://github.com/vladmandic/sd-extension-system-info

AMD SD = Setup Diaster? it was quite troublesome googling the few linux/amdgpu/rocm/sd vers/configs/params posts online. Also the whole PC may hang during generation which is bad for the harddisk. Your card is way more powerful so may not hang like mine. People are getting 8it/s https://vladmandic.github.io/sd-extension-system-info/pages/benchmark.html

According to system info benchmark, M40 is like 1-2 it/s and P4 is barely better than that.

Anyway to properly "benchmark" the impacts different switches on your image generation speed, it is better to use the benchmarking utility from extension https://github.com/vladmandic/sd-extension-system-info (it also creates a very handy table of results from other users at https://vladmandic.github.io/sd-extension-system-info/pages/benchmark.html for you to compare with.

I can see that the top performance benchmark results on SD WebUI Benchmark Data (using RTX 4090), are obtained through WSL2 running Automatic1111 on a Linux dist and Python 3.10.11, along with PyTorch 2.1.0.dev+cu121 (like benchmark id: 4126)

You should be able to compare based on the published benchmarks, just replicate the settings based on what's reported https://vladmandic.github.io/sd-extension-system-info/pages/benchmark.html

Not sure if I completely understand what "Ryzen AI" does, but Tinygrad for example has some limited support for RDNA3[0]. It isn't quite there yet in matters of performance though, as you can read in the comments of that file.

There's also a small tutorial by AMD on how to use the WMMA intrinsic[1] using AMD's hipcc[2] compiler. Documentation is sparse kinda sparse, but the instruction set is not huge. The RDNA3 ISA guide[3] might also be helpful (and only a fraction of the pages are relevant.)

0. https://github.com/tinygrad/tinygrad/blob/master/extra/gemm/...

1. https://gpuopen.com/learn/wmma_on_rdna3/

2. https://github.com/ROCm/HIPCC

3. https://www.amd.com/content/dam/amd/en/documents/radeon-tech...

This post describes how I added automatic differentiation to Tensorken. Tensorken is my attempt to build a fully featured yet easy-to-understand and hackable implementation of a deep learning library in Rust. It takes inspiration from the likes of PyTorch, Tinygrad, and JAX.

what do you think about tinygrad? I think its a good example of growing and well written, (partially) well documented library with many close to reference implementations

The idea of model architecture making fast hardware design easier is what makes https://github.com/tinygrad/tinygrad so interesting.

🌟 Support on GitHub Website: https://tinygrad.org/

Before we begin, make sure you have TinyGrad and the required dependencies installed. You can find the installation instructions here.

Try to get something like tinygrad[1] running locally, that way you can tweak things a bit run it again and see how it performs. While doing this you'll pick up most of the concepts and get a feeling of how things work. Also, take a look at projects like llama.cpp[2], you don't have to fully understand what's going on here, tho.

You may need some intermediate knowledge of linear algebra and this thing called "data science" nowadays, which is pretty much knowing how to mangle data and visualize it.

Try creating a small model on your own, it doesn't have to be super fancy just make sure it does something you want it to do. And then ... you'll probably could go on your own then.

1: https://github.com/tinygrad/tinygrad

2: https://github.com/ggerganov/llama.cpp