mimalloc VS Flutter

mimalloc: mimalloc is an open source implementation of malloc, currently the best performing allocator.

Some compiler writers thought that was the case, if [0] is related to OP. I don't have a "modern" (after 6th gen) Intel CPU to test it on, but note that most programs are compiled for a relatively generic CPU.

[0]: https://github.com/microsoft/mimalloc/issues/807

Yes, it's very efficient and that's not where the main problem lies. However, small allocations with modern C heap allocators like mimalloc or snmalloc has gotten extremely efficient as well. Would be interesting to see a benchmark comparison with Java's G1 and ZGC.

Memory management for C is not itself a solved problem, not only is there a lot of performance to squeeze out of malloc itself (the benchmarks on https://github.com/microsoft/mimalloc exemplifies the variance between the implementations), but it's up to the programmer to implement memory management in the large in an efficient way, which is not an easy task. One sure mark of a slow C program is one with a ton of mallocs and frees strewn all over.

It's a very terse howto for replacing Factorio's memory allocator with Microsoft's mimalloc, and configuring mimalloc so that memory is always allocated on huge pages by using madvise().

I was wondering if Koka's perceus referencing counting style is any different from the reference counting that Lean4 implements? I understand that both rely upon the mimalloc (https://github.com/microsoft/mimalloc) library in the backend.

If you are fine with heap allocations then there are only few dozens operator new/delete to override to regain control over normal C++ code memory use. Allocators and STL all need to call those. At least that's what gaming does on all platforms. If you need examples you can check Mimalloc on github ( https://github.com/microsoft/mimalloc/blob/master/include/mimalloc-new-delete.h ).

What's the difference between this and Microsoft's? https://github.com/microsoft/mimalloc

Version 0.1.31 of the Rust wrapper for the mimalloc memory allocator has just been released!

[3]: https://github.com/flutter/flutter/tree/master/packages/flut...

Thanks - that link does not appear to be open access, anyways I don't think I've seen it. I'm familiar with Flutter at a high-level (Kevin Moore gave a great talk on it at Wasm I/O), and I think other than requiring users to work in Dart, it is probably one of the most powerful ways to do cross-platform UI today.

Worth noting that their original GPU backend was Skia, and now they are retooling around Flutter GPU (Impeller)[0], which is kind of designed similarly as an abstract rendering interface over platform-specific GPU APIs.

[0]https://github.com/flutter/flutter/wiki/Flutter-GPU

If you are considering Electron/React then I would suggest adding Flutter to your list of technologies to consider. It uses Dart (a language similar to C#) and has a lot going for it… relatively quick to get up to speed with, fantastic developer experience (e.g., hot reload, great IDE support, good development tools) and very strong cross-platform support: it generates native iOS, Android, MacOS, Windows and Linux executables. Check it out: https://flutter.dev/

You can find the React Native documentation here and Flutter Documentation here.

[1]https://github.com/flutter/flutter/issues/55092#issuecomment...

> There is actually a great issue thread on the Flutter GitHub that explains exactly why other solutions do not work correctly when compared to hooks [0]

Interesting. I assume you are referring to this comment in particular -> https://github.com/flutter/flutter/issues/51752#issuecomment... ?