flask-login VS Flask-AppBuilder

Are this modules good? https://github.com/flask-admin/flask-admin and https://github.com/maxcountryman/flask-login

flask-login: Provides access to the current username

I use Flask-login and implement role based authentication using decorators.

Flask-Login has a closed Issue #19 on GitHub but it actually doesn't answer my question :-/

You can try to look here https://github.com/maxcountryman/flask-login/blob/main/test_login.py

The example code provided by flask-login does it this way, but this only works because it's pulling the User objects from a global hard-coded dictionary, not as in a real-world scenario like a database, where the DB must be checked and User objects created after the user enters their login credentials. And I can't seem to find any other example code that illustrates using a database with flask-login.

What u/MikeDoesDo said. `flask-login` is rather built for the traditional approach to login and user management. It doesn't have a concept of auth tokens or JWT. It uses traditional cookies. The code that actually sets the cookie for the session isn't robust for a production app. Secure tokens have to be signed with robust keys. In addition to strong tokens, you also need measures that prevent brute-force attacks. Third party systems like auth0 bring all of this and more. Besides, with these systems you delegate the login process to the UI and the backend simply needs to verify incoming tokens. The crucial part is that you verify the token contents (audience and such) and the signature. For a production app with sensitive data and money behind it, don't settle for anything less than this.

https://github.com/maxcountryman/flask-login/blob/c77ba6b12ef5e3045df054cf8bf2d61c4d83f54f/flask_login/mixins.py#L35-L39

This one might be interesting as well: https://github.com/dpgaspar/Flask-AppBuilder

I have spent a ton of time and did a TON of debugging on this. In the interest of my time and not copying information, I have put all the debugging, as well as more information on the issue, on FAB's github page. Here is the link to that to learn more: https://github.com/dpgaspar/Flask-AppBuilder/issues/1957

There's the Flask-Security extension for example. Or the Flask-Appbuilder framework, which does a whole lot more.

You can also try FlaskAppbuilder: https://github.com/dpgaspar/Flask-AppBuilder. Some of the large project like Apache Airflow, Apache Superset are built on top of it.