dotnix VS sops-nix

home-manager and nix: https://github.com/legendofmiracles/dotnix

This allows me to abstract logic easily, have it all modular and have everything be nix.

If you’re interested and want to see more, here’s my massive configuration.

https://github.com/LegendOfMiracles/dotnix/tree/master/hosts... (bottom lines describe the remote build logic) this is the actual config of the pi... One other file also gets sourced: the defaults-nixos file in the root of the repo. And the distributed build host nix file describes creating a build user on my main machine.

The setup is mostly mirrored from https://sgt.hootr.club/molten-matter/nix-distributed-builds/

Config is somewhere in HM/fish.nix :p https://github.com/legendofmiracles/dotnix

https://github.com/legendofmiracles/dotnix inside the secrets dir

For applications, I think environment variables are great. Especially if you adopt nomad because you could also use vault to populate secrets in. For machines that won't work so you'll need something else like https://github.com/Mic92/sops-nix

I've heard good things about and seen sops-nix used on a few really solid configs. Others tend to use Age or Homeage.

You can use something like sops-nix if you're on NixOS https://github.com/Mic92/sops-nix.

Yeah, I don't know how to manage secrets yet. I've read about sops-nix, but I don't have the slightest clue how to integrate it into my own nix-config.

I use sops-nix for that. Secrets are stored encrypted in the store, and decrypted at runtime.

One think I saw that I don't recommend is to change your password after installing; that's not very reporoducible, use users.users..hashedPassword or users.users..passwordFile with agenix or sops-nix.

So, I did some digging. According to the first Dicourse chat that popped up, it's "not possible". That's not an acceptable answer for me ;). I read through HM's appendix to see if there's a mention of private keys there (there weren't). I also know of SOPS (and sops-nix), but that seems to require an SSH/GPG key to decrypt :D.

If you only need secrets management, there are quite a lot of bolt-on solutions with little overhead which are also agnostic to the form of deployment, like https://github.com/Mic92/sops-nix or https://github.com/ryantm/agenix. Personally for my machines I want unattended reboots, so I just copy all keys to the hard disk and manage secrets solely with file permissions.