vodon-player VS ReactFX

If you use Typescript, take a look at: https://mobx-keystone.js.org/

It's an additional layer on top of MobX that adds strong typing. I've been using it for an open source video annotation project and it's been amazing for keeping track of local state, cascading calculations of things.

Here's my "models" directory for it if you want a taste of how it works:

https://github.com/Rodeoclash/vodon-player/blob/main/player/...

You could also write that in many other languages like Clojure (with cljfx for FP fans), Python, Ruby, JavaScript, and of course Java. It would be less verbose if I used a library that better used Kotlin's features, but the goal here is that you can look up the JavaFX APIs from the link above (there are a couple of implied static imports).

So not much different, but it demonstrates how the text property of the label is bound to a dynamically computed string which is in turn bound to an observable number. When the timer fires, the count increases and the label is recomputed. Everything is done that way so layout computations, for example, won't run unless the size of the label changes. And that's it - no need for VDOMs or prop drilling or state memoization or any of these other performance hacks.

At some point you'll observe that this seems a like like "reactive programming" as used on the server side, and then might want to explore a library like ReactFX which connects these two worlds together.

https://github.com/TomasMikula/ReactFX

There are some other nice features in this type of toolkit that the web community seems to be heading towards. I'd be willing to bet a lot that at some point they'll even reinvent inheritance under a new name, because being able to write code that's generic over component trees is really pretty useful. The hooks/functions model totally wrecks that and has led to this explosion of "design systems" (otherwise known as themes), none of which interoperate properly or can be coded against in an abstracted manner.

None of this is to say that FX is perfect or that React/SolidJS etc are the wrong tools to use. You can run FX apps in a browser using a form of server side rendering - check out https://www.jpro.one to see a fully crawlable website that's actually implemented using JavaFX on the server with no frontend/backend split existing at all. But it only works well if you don't have a fast and reliable server connection, plus a server with plenty of RAM and CPU. Alas browsers pull all sorts of mean tricks to keep people locked inside the HTML5 sandbox so JS frameworks aren't going anywhere, but it would be nice if that community spread its wings a bit and looked at prior art from outside their language. GUIs are old and the challenges involved in them aren't new, and from the outside it looks suspiciously like there is no real progress being made here, only wheel spinning.

ReactFX - For cleaner, easier-to-reason event handler composition. Nice!

I've noticed when you look into a lot of classes in some libraries like guava, apache commons, or ReactFX, you'll notice a sort of abstraction pattern. There'll be a class that houses a bunch of common methods. Inside of those methods, instead of putting the relevant logic inside of the method, they'll call an operation-specific class that executes the logic. An example would be PredicateUtils or EventStream. Is there name for this pattern? It doesn't quite seem like it fits the command or service layer patterns.