scope-capture VS datascript

Awesome tools.

Personally I can't imagine coding in clojure without scope capture

https://github.com/vvvvalvalval/scope-capture

I haven't tried it myself. I generally just use truss for runtime constraint checking. I use a modified version that integrates scope-capture. And malli validation for more complex cases, but I try to limit that. For me it is better to validate individual attributes as needed, vs validating an entire "type"/collection of attributes. So each function only cares about the attributes that it needs, and validates only as needed.

Use scope-capture to observe the actual data flowing through the system

Scope capture library https://github.com/vvvvalvalval/scope-capture automates this approach.

Is anyone aware of any prior art along the lines of this? I've seen scope-capture but it's more about instrumenting existing programs than writing new ones interactively.

I am not advocating against the use of a compiler. I am going to illustrate how to reproduce the scope of a program and replay it in the REPL as it is done for instance in Clojure with scope-capture. In some use cases, I find this approach is simpler than using a debugger. This approach is possible only because the data is immutable.

Hi pests, I don't think the criticism in the comments gives a full picture.

I wrote about a particular flavor of datalog, in common use today. [1] [2]. The earliest representation I know, which matches the syntax of my essay, was in SICP [3]

There's another, more academic form of datalog, which looks a lot more like prolog. Both have lots of similarities: both systems have a set of facts and rules. Both systems have can take a partially filled fact or rule, and find all matching facts. The more academic flavors of Datalog are useful for general logic, and particularly powerful for recursive questions. The variant I showed is more tailed for database queries.

[1] https://github.com/tonsky/datascript

There is also datascript as a similar option.

What's the use case for relic? Sounds similar to https://github.com/tonsky/datascript ?

This look nice !

Datascript seems to be another Datalog engine (in memory only)

https://github.com/tonsky/datascript

Inspired by past work: LINQ, inline-python, crepe, DataScript, Riffle.

An in-memory database like Datascript may be worth looking into. Otherwise you could take an indexing approach: put all the data into one big map indexed by some unique key, and have a bunch of supplementary indexes that are updated on insertion.