nfdump VS pmacct

Compare nfdump vs pmacct and see what are their differences.

pmacct

pmacct is a small set of multi-purpose passive network monitoring tools [NetFlow IPFIX sFlow libpcap BGP BMP RPKI IGP Streaming Telemetry]. (by pmacct)
Our great sponsors
  • InfluxDB - Power Real-Time Data Analytics at Scale
  • WorkOS - The modern identity platform for B2B SaaS
  • SaaSHub - Software Alternatives and Reviews
nfdump pmacct
4 8
735 1,017
- 2.5%
9.6 9.2
8 days ago 3 days ago
C C
GNU General Public License v3.0 or later GNU General Public License v3.0 or later
The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives.
Stars - the number of stars that a project has on GitHub. Growth - month over month growth in stars.
Activity is a relative number indicating how actively a project is being developed. Recent commits have higher weight than older ones.
For example, an activity of 9.0 indicates that a project is amongst the top 10% of the most actively developed projects that we are tracking.

nfdump

Posts with mentions or reviews of nfdump. We have used some of these posts to build our list of alternatives and similar projects. The last one was on 2023-03-24.
  • Netflow collector software for lab purpose
    3 projects | /r/networking | 24 Mar 2023
    https://github.com/phaag/nfdump its an "simple" collector. It is just an CLI tool. If you can utilize the cli it's a monster to analyze the raw data. if you need a fancy gui then this is the wrong collector.
  • real-time analytics / traffic capture on MX204
    3 projects | /r/Juniper | 1 Nov 2022
    Try the open source nfdump (this should also be a package in Debian/Ubuntu at least). You would configure 'nfcapd' to receive netflow data, then process it with 'nfdump' which is a commandline tool for obtaining statistics on traffic (e.g. top N IPs for bytes/flows, etc).
  • Cisco Netflow Help
    1 project | /r/networking | 7 Mar 2022
  • netflow analyzier free tools
    1 project | /r/sysadmin | 9 Apr 2021
    For the quick look nfdump https://github.com/phaag/nfdump is in use. Since it is a CLI tool, it is not really suitable for managers.

pmacct

Posts with mentions or reviews of pmacct. We have used some of these posts to build our list of alternatives and similar projects. The last one was on 2023-05-16.
  • NetFlow-equivalent analysis for mirrored traffic
    1 project | /r/networking | 12 Jul 2023
    If you want a tool that can ingest from a span port and generate netflow or IPFIX there is pmacct. This should work with your existing tooling that collects netflow data.
  • Looking for network traffic analysis solution
    2 projects | /r/networking | 16 May 2023
  • Free netflow collector that forwards messages to a syslog server?
    3 projects | /r/networking | 10 Apr 2023
    Your best bet is probably pmacct. I don't think this functionality is built-in per se, but it would be fairly easy to use syslog-ng or similar to read its output from file or stdout. It can also aggregate for you, if that's useful.
  • How to locate device illegally downloading on network
    1 project | /r/networking | 6 May 2022
  • IPv4 vs IPv6 traffic stats
    1 project | /r/mikrotik | 4 Jan 2022
  • Benchmarking: TimescaleDB vs. ClickHouse
    7 projects | news.ycombinator.com | 3 Nov 2021
    While I'm not a current customer of Timescale, I do use the open source version of Timescale extensively, so I feel like I can summarize some of the benefits of Timescale over other TSDB's. The company is a mid size, with awkward data 4+PB unstructured data, with our Postgres cluster hosting about 20 TB of data.

    The main advantage from my perspective, is that you can query across data business data and time series data with all the advantages that Postgres has. Time series data while useful on its own, becomes incredibly powerful when it can be combined with your business and production data.

    A great example is our outbound network data monitoring. We use pmacct http://www.pmacct.net/ to send network flows to Postgres from our firewall, host inventory data in Postgres, and a foreign data wrapper around our LDAP data to determine user / host assignment, and from that we can correlate every data flow to the user who is assigned to the host that generated that particular flow. This makes for some pretty powerful security reporting. Outside of that, we use Timescale's hypertables in a number of places that aren't explicitly timeseries data, like syslog data, web server logs, etc. This allows for some pretty amazing reporting on log data that is timeboxed, like "give me all the 500 errors from our HTTP log that have an ip address in Finland (did I mention that we load GeoIP data into Postgres every night) in the last 3.5 hours.

    Timescale is excellent on its own, and honestly competitive with other TSDB's on its own. Having access to the full Postgres ecosystem with your timeseries data makes Timescale way ahead of everyone else. My story might change when I hit the limits of what a single Postgres host can ingest, but I'm not even close to that scale yet.

    Other advantages of Timescale, is having access to real SQL, you don't have to learn a new domain specific query language, you can just use SQL. This admittedly can be a double edge sword. SQL is more complicated than PromQL / InfluxQL, however that comes with quite a lot of extra capability, and the ability to transfer that knowledge into other domains.

    I personally really like Timescale, and feel that regardless of anyones benchmarks, no matter how well thought out or not, the advantages outweigh the disadvantages by a pretty large margin.

  • Port Mirror and GoFlow Collector
    1 project | /r/networking | 5 Sep 2021
    GoFlow doesn't capture raw packets, it accepts IPFIX/Netflow/sFlow. You will either need to configure your equipment to generate that flow data and send it to the goflow collector, or use an application like pacct to capture packets and generate IPFIX/Netflow data from it.
  • FRRouting and IPFix/Netflow
    2 projects | /r/networking | 30 Jul 2021
    https://github.com/pmacct/pmacct is the best exporter I've found. I can pull some old configs for pmacct if you're interested. You can either BGP peer pmacct to FRR to enrich IPFIX with ASNs or you can even instruct pmacct to read prefix to AS mappings from a file.

What are some alternatives?

When comparing nfdump and pmacct you can also consider the following projects:

ntopng - Web-based Traffic and Security Network Traffic Monitoring

FastNetMon - FastNetMon - very fast DDoS sensor with sFlow/Netflow/IPFIX/SPAN support

softflowd - softflowd: A flow-based network traffic analyser capable of Cisco NetFlow data export software.

nDPI - Open Source Deep Packet Inspection Software Toolkit

silk - Silk File Reader

VictoriaMetrics - VictoriaMetrics: fast, cost-effective monitoring solution and time series database

goflow - The high-scalability sFlow/NetFlow/IPFIX collector used internally at Cloudflare.

promscale - [DEPRECATED] Promscale is a unified metric and trace observability backend for Prometheus, Jaeger and OpenTelemetry built on PostgreSQL and TimescaleDB.

akvorado - Flow collector, enricher and visualizer

ipt-netflow - Netflow iptables module for Linux kernel (official)

flow-pipeline - A set of tools and examples to run a flow-pipeline (sFlow, NetFlow)

clickhouse_fdw - ClickHouse FDW for PostgreSQL