google-authenticator VS ProtonMail Web Client

otpauth:// is a de-factor standard, since Google Authenticator uses it: https://github.com/google/google-authenticator/wiki/Key-Uri-...

Random question if you're using TOTP why not just give the user the secret when signing up as a Google Authenticator URI encoded in a QR code? Then you won't need to futz around with sending it to them afterwards. You can even use a library like qrcode.js so you don't generate the barcode server side either.

Locker can generate Time Based OTP codes parsing TOTP urls stored under a special key named totp.

(Examples> https://github.com/google/google-authenticator/wiki/Key-Uri-Format)

If we're talking about the encrypted Authy TOTP secrets and IF they get cracked or guessed, Authy does store the email in the name of the item. Having the name, service and the secret within the QR code's URI is normal and the standard for TOTP. The only thing the hackers won't have is the password.

The source code is here https://github.com/ProtonMail/WebClients

> Finally, in keeping with our long track record of transparency, Proton Pass is open source so anyone can review and verify our security architecture

They sure do enjoy writing that sentence without including any hyperlinks. This (https://github.com/ProtonMail/WebClients/tree/main/applicati...) appears to be the browser extension and https://github.com/ProtonMail/WebClients/tree/main/packages/... appears to look like the backend referenced in the extension's readme, but that directory's readme is zero bytes so (shrug)

Fork the frontend and make your own lightweight option

PS: I hope that we selfhosters will have a modern, efficient, easy to use mail suite one day with modern features like JMAP, good self-learning spam integration, automated checks and validations for SPF/DMARC/DKIM or whether the IP/host suddenly appears in a blocklist and integrated encryption at rest for emails. Something that isn't 30 services in a container image, with 30 different configuration styles. Maybe even with an API integrated that's compatible to the ProtonMail frontend (like the neutron server once intended to be). Anyway, I'm sorry for dreaming. ;)

And if you want to customize it further you can use Stylus to add custom CSS, Tampermonkey to add JS, or even modify the whole thing yourself from source (if you run it locally it syncs with your actual account).

There are lots of useful End to end encrypted webapps such as Protonmail, cryptpad, cryptee and many others. And part of why we trust them is that the client side code is open source, so we can see that end to end encryption is really going on and is really secure. Its impossible to verify what code they are running in their server, but if the data we send them is already encrypted we can rest easy.