Apache Camel VS aws-cloudformation-coverage-roadmap

"correct" is a value judgement that depends on lots of different things. Only you can decide which tool is correct. Here are some ideas:

- https://camel.apache.org/

- https://www.windmill.dev/

- https://github.com/huginn/huginn

Your idea about a queue (in redis, or postgres, or sqlite, etc) is also totally valid. These off-the-shelf tools I listed probably wouldn't give you a huge advantage IMO.

Apache Camel Apache Nifi Spring Cloud

This reminds me more of Apache Camel[0] than other things it's being compared to.

> The process initiator puts a message on a queue, and another processor picks that up (probably on a different service, on a different host, and in different code base) - does some processing, and puts its (intermediate) result on another queue

This is almost exactly the definition of message routing (ie: Camel).

I'm a bit doubtful about the pitch because the solution is presented as enabling you to maintain synchronous style programming while achieving benefits of async processing. This just isn't true, these are fundamental tradeoffs. If you need a synchronous answer back then no amount of queuing, routing, prioritisation, etc etc will save you when the fundamental resource providing that is unavailable, and the ultimate outcome that your synchronous client now hangs indefinitely waiting for a reply message instead of erroring hard and fast is not desirable at all. If you go into this ad hoc, and build in a leaky abstraction that asynchronous things are are actually synchronous and vice versa, before you know it you are going to have unstable behaviour or even worse, deadlocks all over your system and the worst part - the true state of the system is now hidden in which messages are pending in transient message queues everywhere.

What really matters here is to fundamentally design things from the start with patterns that allow you to be very explicit about what needs to be synchronous vs async (building on principles of idempotency, immutability, coherence, to maximise the cases where async is the answer).

The notion of Apache Camel is to make all these decisions a first class elements of your framework and then to extract out the routing layer as a dedicated construct. The fact it generalises beyond message queues (treating literally anything that can provide a piece of data as a message provider) is a bonus.

[0] https://camel.apache.org/

Since you're writing a Java app to consume this, I highly recommend Apache Camel to do the consuming of messages for it. You can trivially aim it at file systems, message queues, databases, web services and all manner of other sources to grab your data for you, and you can change your mind about what that source is, without having to rewrite most of your client code.

For a simple sequential Pipeline, my goto would be Apache Camel. As soon as you want complexity its either Apache Nifi or a micro service architecture.

🐪 Apache Camel : Camel JBang, A JBang-based Camel app for easily running Camel routes.

Apache Camel

So, my advice is this. Expand your knowledge. Pursue higher education on topics you are familiar with, but also explore topics you are not. Read documentation, but question it. I just found out about something called Apache Camel today that I am excited to read up on. Why is it better than Spring? Is it really? What's happening here? This is always what excites me as a developer and engineer. There is so much to learn.

Given AWS CloudFormation is AWS's native language and service for infrastructure as code, you will likely find more official quickstarts provided by AWS in the language. In addition to this, AWS Support will probably be more capable of assisting you with issues when you need help. AWS Support is essential for large enterprises, particularly those new to the cloud or slow to adopt. These types of organizations may have a skill gap within their organization regarding their cloud skill set, and in turn, they are more likely to use AWS Enterprise Support.

Today, I will show you how to build Amazon Location Service, which allows you to build location-based applications within your AWS environment using AWS Cloud Development Kit (AWS CDK) and AWS CloudFormation. I will also show examples of the recently popular CDK Migrate and AWS CloudFormation IaC generator.

AWS CloudFormation: Speed up cloud provisioning with infrastructure as code.

Infrastructure as Code (IaC) is an important part of any true hosting operation in the public cloud. Each of these platforms has their own IaC solution, e.g. AWS CloudFormation. But they also support popular open-source IaC tools like Pulumi or Terraform. A category of tools that also needs to be discussed is API gateways and other app-specific load balancers. There are applications for internal consumption, which can be called microservices if you have a lot of them. And often microservices use advanced networking options such as a service mesh instead of just the native private network offered by a VPC.

Cloudformation (IaC) does not need to be introduced to anyone, plus if you read the previous blogpost, the terraform provider (CC) we used is based on Cloudformation. Moreover, you will notice a lot of similarities, after all, we are implementing the same scenario, but with a different tool.

AWS Application Composer launched in the AWS Console at re:Invent one year ago, and this re:Invent it expanded to the VS Code IDE as part of the AWS Toolkit - but that’s not the only exciting part. When using App Composer in the IDE, users also get access to a generative AI partner that will help them write infrastructure as code (IaC) for all 1100+ AWS CloudFormation resources that Application Composer now supports.

CloudFormation

Of course, best practices today dictate that we should be deploying our infrastructure as code, using tools such as CloudFormation or Terraform.

If you're provisioning the above resources for the first time, you'll have to either configure Terraform to use specific AWS keys as you won't have OIDC connection yet. In my case, I chose to have those pre-requesites resources in a CloudFormation template and deploy them with StackSets.