RiseOfTheRunelords VS CurseOfTheCrimsonThrone

Rise of the Runelords in 2e! I've been using the conversion guide from A Series of Dice-Based Events. We're just at the end of book 4 after almost 2 years of weekly sessions. The party is currently having a rough go against the leveled-up Hounds of Tindalos) guarding Mokmurian's lair. Currently only the invisible rogue is left standing, and I've asked the party to make back-up characters for a potential rescue mission, just in case things go south :)

I'm using this https://github.com/A-Series-of-Dice-Based-Events/RiseOfTheRunelords to run RotR for my players, and it has worked pretty good. No idea if you can find conversions for other APs.

Obviously you want an official port, but for anyone who's interested in the community port, here it is.

​Rise of the Runelords

It's very feasible, the first PF2e campaign that I ran was RotRL, up until halfway through book 5 when we decided to embark on something else. Essentially, you take the story and rebuild the encounters and treasure with PF2e materials. This github has done most of the work in that regard.

There's an effort to convert some of the 1e APs to 2e: https://github.com/A-Series-of-Dice-Based-Events/RiseOfTheRunelords

So I agree that this probably shouldn't be suggested to OP. However, for anyone else reading this topic and wondering about it, Rise of the Runelords has already been converted to 2e over on A Series of Dice-Based Events.

Several other 1st edition APs have also been converted by the community, such as Curse of the Crimson Throne, Hells Rebels, Rise of the Runelords, and a number of others (to varying degrees) at the A Series of Dice-Based Events github. All these do still require the original material, and are somewhat more work than the 2e published APs, but if those aren't doing it for you and your group these options do also exist without having to convert everything yourself.

Rise of the Runelords

There's a Discord community and GIT repository called "A Series of Dice Based Events" that has full or partial conversions for all the 1E APs. Here's the Crimson Throne one.

That said, if you don't want to do that, I think Rise of the Runelords or Curse of the Crimson Throne are your best bet. Those are 1e APs (extremely popular ones!), but completed community conversions are available of both of those to 2e (linked above). There is also a completed community conversion of Skulls and Shackles - the "you're a pirate" AP, but that doesn't seem to fit the bill that you're looking for.

You should merge this back into https://github.com/A-Series-of-Dice-Based-Events/CurseOfTheCrimsonThrone