MultiPar VS snapraid

but... depending on how much effort you want to spend fixing it I might be able to fix your current corrupt files, especially if the corrupt files are only mildly corrupt I could create a '.par2' file from mine (assuming you are on build 1436.28), then you would use MultiPar (i.e. https://github.com/Yutaka-Sawada/MultiPar/releases ) to scan your files and it will tell me how many blocks you need to fix it and then I could create recovery data with MultiPar. doing this might dramatically lower the amount of data I would have to upload as then you could use MultiPar which will fix your current corrupt files so they match mine identically.

MultiPar is the continuation for Windows https://github.com/Yutaka-Sawada/MultiPar

And this for Linux https://github.com/animetosho/par2cmdline-turbo

* MultiPar supports in-situ repair, which bypasses this problem entirely

To detect bitrot I use dynamix file integrity plugin, it compute Blake3 hash for each file, it is stored as extend attribute. You Can choose which share will be covered. For correction i then use par2 files using multipar https://hp.vector.co.jp/authors/VA021385/ https://github.com/Yutaka-Sawada/MultiPar (Windows only, par2cmdline for Linux. You could compile from source and add it to unraid if you want, i've done it for testing purpose)

And last but not less important - make regular parity files of your healthy important data, and store them somewhere. MultiPar is your best friend. Even if your data gets corrupt, with parity files you can restore it to it's former glory. Some limitations will apply, read the manual.

This is possible with MultiPar https://github.com/Yutaka-Sawada/MultiPar

More sanely, perhaps, get some M-Disc DVDs (if you can find real ones - apparently they're becoming just normal DVDs) and put one file on each, and then run https://github.com/Yutaka-Sawada/MultiPar on it to create parity files. Then store the file, the parity files, and the software you need (MultiPar) on the disc. To be safe, you probably also need to store the DVD burner you used to make it, as those are getting thin on the ground these days.

Note about par2: if one is using a windows system with a nvidia GPU this version of par2 is faster as it speaks CUDA.

For any file repairs use multipar, it's still being updated and has gpu acceleration. https://github.com/Yutaka-Sawada/MultiPar/releases

Would mergerfs and snapraid work for you? You'd sacrifice a disk to parity and run the parity calc manually, but you could set up a cron job for that.

If you are using OpenMediaVault, checkout SnapRaid plugin.

I used drivepool for years with snapraid before I switched over to unraid. Nothing but good things to say about either program. Highly recommend both.

You can always use SnapRAID . there is no user interface, it is CLI. also you have to sync it manually. or set up a cronjob. you loose a hdd like unRaid or RAID5 but it gives you parity. then you could always use duplicati and backblaze business to make backups. it isnt as expensive as you would think for a homelab. the first back up might be a little much but then its pennies after that

As for the drives I'm thinking of grabbing a few from ServerPartDeals and upgrading my setup that uses DrivePool and snapRAID, but in Linux you would use mergerfs instead of DrivePool.

I myself prescribe to the teachings of the IronicBadger(Alex Kretzshmar) from the Self-Hosted podcast and (when I get one setup) intend to follow the guides on his site https://perfectmediaserver.com and use mergerfs to turn a JBOD to a single filesystem and use SnapRAID for redundancy.

I have that exact Sabrent 5 bay enclosure and I replaced it with this Orico 5 bay enclosure because the Sabrent's connection would fail while I ran snapraid sync, but the Orico has never failed me.

With two drives? Just run them as-is. Once you get a third disk, set up https://www.snapraid.it. Then as you add more, just follow https://www.snapraid.it/faq#howmanypar to have the correct number of parity disks. Or don't, Plex content is probably easy to re-acquire if you need to so having redundancy or a backup isn't all that important.