workers-sdk VS workers-rs

Workers

https://github.com/cloudflare/workers-sdk/blob/main/packages...

The Wrangler, Cloudflare's Developer Platform command-line interface (CLI), allows you to manage Worker projects and has an in-built Miniflare, which runs an HTTP server.

/** * Welcome to Cloudflare Workers! This is your first worker. * * - Run `npm run dev` in your terminal to start a development server * - Open a browser tab at http://localhost:8787/ to see your worker in action * - Run `npm run deploy` to publish your worker * * Learn more at https://developers.cloudflare.com/workers/ */ export interface Env { // Example binding to KV. Learn more at https://developers.cloudflare.com/workers/runtime-apis/kv/ // MY_KV_NAMESPACE: KVNamespace; // // Example binding to Durable Object. Learn more at https://developers.cloudflare.com/workers/runtime-apis/durable-objects/ // MY_DURABLE_OBJECT: DurableObjectNamespace; // // Example binding to R2. Learn more at https://developers.cloudflare.com/workers/runtime-apis/r2/ // MY_BUCKET: R2Bucket; // // Example binding to a Service. Learn more at https://developers.cloudflare.com/workers/runtime-apis/service-bindings/ // MY_SERVICE: Fetcher; // // Example binding to a Queue. Learn more at https://developers.cloudflare.com/queues/javascript-apis/ // MY_QUEUE: Queue; } export default { async fetch(request: Request, env: Env, ctx: ExecutionContext): Promise { return new Response('Hello World!'); }, };

$ npm create cloudflare@latest using create-cloudflare version 2.9.0 ╭ Create an application with Cloudflare Step 1 of 3 │ ├ In which directory do you want to create your application? │ dir ./apps/worker │ ├ What type of application do you want to create? │ type "Hello World" Worker │ ├ Do you want to use TypeScript? │ yes typescript │ ├ Copying files from "hello-world" template │ ├ Retrieving current workerd compatibility date │ compatibility date 2023-12-18 │ ╰ Application created ╭ Installing dependencies Step 2 of 3 │ ├ Installing dependencies │ installed via `npm install` │ ├ Installing @cloudflare/workers-types │ installed via npm │ ├ Adding latest types to `tsconfig.json` │ skipped couldn't find latest compatible version of @cloudflare/workers-types │ ╰ Dependencies Installed ╭ Deploy with Cloudflare Step 3 of 3 │ ├ Do you want to deploy your application? │ no deploy via `npm run deploy` │ ├ APPLICATION CREATED Deploy your application with npm run deploy │ │ Navigate to the new directory cd apps/worker │ Run the development server npm run start │ Deploy your application npm run deploy │ Read the documentation https://developers.cloudflare.com/workers │ Stuck? Join us at https://discord.gg/cloudflaredev │ ╰ See you again soon!

Except that there is. Cloudflare is pretty great for free SSL certificates and DNS management, but they also offer a free Workers plan. A Cloudflare worker is basically JavaScript code that runs on Cloudflare's edge network and handles HTTP traffic. You can do a lot with workers, including modifying/rewriting HTML responses. You can probably see where this is going: If a worker can modify HTML responses, then it can inject the umami script into every HTML response.

Cloudflare Workers

And what about the DX of using Workers with Pages?

I tried to use that recently and it was a disaster. I wrote about my experience here:

https://twitter.com/pierbover/status/1641474067013271552

I then opened these two issues:

https://github.com/cloudflare/workers-sdk/issues/2962

https://github.com/cloudflare/workers-sdk/issues/2964

I ended up moving the project over to Netlify + Edge functions. I had it all working in like 5-10 mins as it should. Took me two hours to figure out why Workers weren't working in my Pages project, and could never get Workers working properly with my Astro project.

I think you're working exclusively on the engine of Workers which is really top notch, but Cloudflare really needs to improve the outer layer which affects DX considerably.

If you think this is a bug, please open an issue at: https://github.com/cloudflare/workers-sdk/issues/new/choose ```

- The speed of the Python interpreter running in WebAssembly

Today, Python cold starts are slower than cold starts for a JavaScript Worker of equivalent size. A basic "Hello World" Worker written in JavaScript has a near zero cold start time, while a Python Worker has a cold start under 1 second.

That's because we still need to load Pyodide into your Worker on-demand when a request comes in. The blog post describes what we're working on to reduce this — making Pyodide already available upfront.

Once a Python Worker has gone through a cold start though, the differences are more on the margins — maybe a handful milliseconds, depending on what happens during the request.

- There is a slight cost (think — microseconds not milliseconds) to crossing the "bridge" between JavaScript and WebAssembly — for example, by performing I/O or async operations. This difference tends to be minimal — generally something measured in microseconds not milliseconds. People with performance sensitive Workers already write them in Rust https://github.com/cloudflare/workers-rs, which also relies on bridging between JavaScript and WebAssembly.

- The Python interpreter that Pyodide provides, that runs in WebAssembly, isn't as fast as the years and years of optimization that have gone into making JavaScript fast in V8. But it's still relatively early days for Pyodide, compared to the JS engine in V8 — there are parts of its code where we think there are big perf gains to be had. We're looking forward to upstreaming performance improvements, and there are WebAssembly proposals that help here too.

Not yet, but we're working on that https://github.com/cloudflare/workers-rs/pull/324

I'm also in the Workers org but I have had a bit of interaction with Rust. There's some Rust in the Workers runtime using lol-html for HTMLRewriter as well as some tooling and there's the full blown workers-rs framework that I work on, but that's about it for the Rust I work on regularly.

I'm an engineer at Cloudflare working on Workers (and a maintainer of workers-rs) and I'd love to help whoever ends up maintaining this get that PR rewriting it in Rust across the line.

GitHub - cloudflare/workers-rs: Write Cloudflare Workers in 100% Rust via WebAssembly

I never said it was, but thankfully nowadays there are plenty of other tools that are fast enough to keep the dev cycle quick. Personally esbuild is my go-to when I need a bundler but I've grown really fond of SWC native api, we used to use it at work for our wasm build tool for our workers-rs framework.

There's actually a rust framework for Workers https://github.com/cloudflare/workers-rs

I'm a maintainer of the of the Cloudflare workers-rs project to allow you to write serverless functions in Rust running as WASM in our V8-based runtime. There's certainly some rough spots (doesn't have complete parity with our default JS runtime apis), but if you're concerned with cold start times and you don't need a full containerized environment I think it's a solid choice.

Most likely, it should, we just haven't had the time to fully implement it or add a library to wrap the FFI. Please let us know you need a feature by opening an issue.

I may be biased, as the original project author, but I’d recommend using Cloudflare Workers https://github.com/cloudflare/workers-rs - totally free their with very generous limits.