redux-ecosystem-links VS crux

Yeah, from 2016-2018 I spent a lot of time cataloguing Redux-related libraries in the ecosystem, and I definitely saw several addons that were meant to record Redux actions and send them to a server for devs to use in debugging. Totally feasible! (and tbh that's the kind of thing Redux was meant to enable in the first place.)

FWIW, there are some various other third-party replacements for combineReducers that might be useful (see https://github.com/markerikson/redux-ecosystem-links/blob/master/reducers.md ), but you'd have to specifically choose to use them yourself, and on top of that createSlice wouldn't be expecting a third arg or pass it through to its case reducers.

I built a simple router in about 50 lines: https://github.com/andyjessop/crux/blob/main/apps/dev/src/shared/router/router.service.ts

For comparison, I'm writing a front-end framework where the entire size (including router, data fetching/caching, state management) is less than the size of axios.

It's like looking in a mirror. This is exactly why I'm working on crux. Seeing as you have similar thoughts, I'd love to hear your feedback.

Immer's a cool library if you don't mind doing this at the top of every reducer: /* eslint-disable no-param-reassign */. I normally prefer some kind of immutable merge function, like this:

Wow, you've done an amazing job there. I prefer your syntax over RTKQuery, and I really like the idea of the queue. I'm implementing a similar kind of thing myself, except just for redux and not as fully-featured as your solution.

Yeah I get this. I would say two things. Firstly, this is aimed primarily at people who are already using Redux. And secondly (and more importantly), Redux itself is not inherently complex - you can write it in 20 lines of code - it's just that the accepted best practices add lots of boilerplate. I've addressed this in my createSlice library, which removes all but the most essential code from the config: https://github.com/andyjessop/crux/tree/main/packages/redux-slice

100% agree (both with your opinion and that it's controversial), that's why I'm working on my own framework that attempts to solve this issue: https://github.com/andyjessop/crux

I don't think there's an issue with boilerplate in Redux any more, especially with RTK's prevalence. I made my own createSlice that simplifies the creation of reducers and actions still further - it has an extremely straightforward API and is only 30 or so lines of code.

It's not ready for production yet (far from it), but here it is if anyone is interested in finding out more and/or contributing: https://github.com/andyjessop/crux