pdp7-unix VS unix-v6

TIL there is a version of UNIX for PDP-7, and PDP-7 did not have MMU, therefore UNIX by definition do not require MMU, and that version of UNIX had been archeologied in a runnable form on GitHub[1]

1: https://github.com/DoctorWkt/pdp7-unix

I've never heard of a copy being used outside of the original authors' site. However, it can be built from source code and run on a PDP-7 emulator. https://github.com/DoctorWkt/pdp7-unix.

Well first of all I was wrong -- the PDP7 did have syscalls, I'm just bad at reading PDP7 assembly and missed the dispatcher. Curiously, it looks like the sequence is entirely different, although there could be some magic that makes the order different than it appears at first glance.

https://github.com/DoctorWkt/pdp7-unix/blob/master/src/sys/s...

It's all just guessing, but I figure the explanation is much simpler -- for PDP11 UNIX, they just kept using the same syscalls up till V7 / 2BSD, and there should have been a sort of "rolling release" binary compatibility. For the VAX, the first port (32v) probably just retained the original numbering since there was no reason to deviate from it, which colored 3BSD and 4BSD, hence {Net,Free,Open}BSD and Darwin and friends.

Worth pointing out that several versions of Linux have rather different syscall tables. 32 bit ARM and x86 are more-or-less matches, with ARM differing on a few early syscalls, while 64 bit ARM and amd64 differing quite dramatically. The old ABI for 32bit MIPS also matches, but both the n32 and n64 ABIs use slightly variant syscall tables. PowerPC 32/64 bit is also a close match, although it has some impedance (I think it matches closer to AIX by design)

At the end of the day, I think the similarity is mostly a mixture of coincidence, system developers being influenced by their bootstrap system's syscall tables, and no real reason to change them up. No reason to not change them, either, since it's pretty trivial to use different dispatch tables for different types of processes, like how the BSD's handle other-OS compat.

Here's the proof. https://github.com/memnoth/unix-v6/blob/master/source/s1/bc.y I'm going to try to see if this still compiles

You are probably right.

The one in FreeBSD is from NetBSD: https://svnweb.freebsd.org/base/head/usr.bin/units/units.c?v...

The NetBSD version is from Adrian Mariano: http://cvsweb.netbsd.org/bsdweb.cgi/src/usr.bin/units/units....

The one in Plan9 is in yacc: http://9p.io/sources/plan9/sys/src/cmd/units.y

This GitHub repo claims to be V6: https://github.com/memnoth/unix-v6/blob/master/source/s2/uni...