R710-Fan-Control VS freebsd-r720

Compare R710-Fan-Control vs freebsd-r720 and see what are their differences.

R710-Fan-Control

A fork of R710-IPMI-TEMP from NoLooseEnds/Scripts, generalised to a fan control daemon for Dell Poweredge servers. Has reported to work on R710s, R520, R730. Allows more flexible control of the fan throttling vs the vanilla iDrac control which tends to ramp the fans up to full velocity the moment you add non-Dell hardware. (by spacelama)

freebsd-r720

scripts to manage a dell r720 running FreeBSD (by edlitmus)
Our great sponsors
  • InfluxDB - Power Real-Time Data Analytics at Scale
  • WorkOS - The modern identity platform for B2B SaaS
  • SaaSHub - Software Alternatives and Reviews
R710-Fan-Control freebsd-r720
7 3
40 4
- -
3.0 0.0
11 months ago over 1 year ago
Perl Shell
- -
The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives.
Stars - the number of stars that a project has on GitHub. Growth - month over month growth in stars.
Activity is a relative number indicating how actively a project is being developed. Recent commits have higher weight than older ones.
For example, an activity of 9.0 indicates that a project is amongst the top 10% of the most actively developed projects that we are tracking.

R710-Fan-Control

Posts with mentions or reviews of R710-Fan-Control. We have used some of these posts to build our list of alternatives and similar projects. The last one was on 2023-04-25.
  • R730XD Considerations
    3 projects | /r/homelab | 25 Apr 2023
    For the noise, if it becomes a problem that you can't tune through idrac, then keep an eye on my fan control daemon on github. I am just getting my R730xd online now (came here to reddit to see whether anyone else is annoyed that https://linux.dell.com has just gone offline, after successfully using it all day to get firmware updated), and plan on continuing to use that daemon if necessary (it runs on my R520 that the 730xd will eventually replace). I'll push changes through as I discover issues.
  • Passing arguments in Perl?
    2 projects | /r/perl | 2 Mar 2023
  • PowerEdge 730xd Homelab Server Feedback
    2 projects | /r/homelab | 30 Nov 2022
    - If you install drives that it doesn't understand the temperature sensor output from (my WD Blues, for example), the fan minimum will punch up to 66%. You can override this by disabling the automatic fan control and operating the fans yourself. There are a few scripts out there, like the PowerEdge Shutup script (which you run on a remote device like a rPi) and u/spacelama's R710 Fan Control script (which I use on my R730xd fine). Only downside is fans are super high during startup and shutdown, even compared to the normal high fans on startup
  • Noisy Dell R730XD
    1 project | /r/homelab | 7 Nov 2022
    I use https://github.com/spacelama/R710-Fan-Control/ on my R730XD, as I have non-Dell SSDs installed and it's the only way to keep fans below 60%. You need to enable the virtual network interface for iDRAC to be connected to directly from your running OS, otherwise you will need to setup a user for the script to connect as over your regular network.
  • Dell R730 questions
    2 projects | /r/homelab | 24 Sep 2022
    u/gambcl, here is the script I have on mine to control the fans. It adjusts for load and can hand back fan control to the Dirac if it is unable to keep temps down reasonably. I have it running as a SystemD unit. All credit to u/spacelama for making it work!
  • Question regarding Dell R730XD
    1 project | /r/homelab | 4 Sep 2022
    If you are installing NVMe drives, you can't boot from them if they are installed via PCIe risers or adapters, except for Dell's "NVMe Enablement Kit" to use up to 4 U.2 drives. Installing it breaches the "Fresh Air" conditions of the iDRAC though, and the fans will idle around 40% minimum. You would have to override the automatic fan control via IPMI on every boot to have them idle lower. u/spacelama wrote a script for their R710, and I have some bug reports to get it to also work on my R730XD, you can find it here (and discussion here) if needed.

freebsd-r720

Posts with mentions or reviews of freebsd-r720. We have used some of these posts to build our list of alternatives and similar projects. The last one was on 2022-09-24.

What are some alternatives?

When comparing R710-Fan-Control and freebsd-r720 you can also consider the following projects:

serverManager - IPMI server manager build for Dell 12th gen servers

ReBarUEFI - Resizable BAR for (almost) any UEFI system

PowerEdge-shutup - shell ballgag for Dell servers, tested working with G11 and G12, G13 and G14 too but with conditions**.