CodeReviewer.vim VS vim-bookmarks

After posting this, I started looking into https://github.com/vim-scripts/CodeReviewer.vim. It's quite good and fulfils most of what I want. It's also really simple enough for me to modify if needed. This satisfies what I need, but please feel free to comment

This is the plugin which I had used earlier - https://github.com/vim-scripts/CodeReviewer.vim. I have modified it to be able to use different comment files and to jump to the file location for each comment (there are no tags like a quickfix). [This VS code extension](https://github.com/vsls-contrib/codetour) functionality is what I am eventually looking for. I still think a quickfix kind of interface would be the best.

For vim I use the CodeReviewer plugin [1] to capture comments for files. I modified it to use differently named comment files and to jump to the file locations from the comment line. I am planning to include support for hierarchical comments or referring other comment files from within one. Also the problem of tracking code changes or referring to a certain git commit is still there - in clearcase it can be easily done with a reference to the branch, but not sure how to do it in git.

[1] https://github.com/vim-scripts/CodeReviewer.vim

Looks like https://github.com/MattesGroeger/vim-bookmarks won't do it, because:

I currently use https://github.com/MattesGroeger/vim-bookmarks but it's definitely not sufficient since it provides a tiny space for editing. It's good all-around, and I might spend time to modify it, but if there's an existing tool, I'd absolutely love that

vim-bookmarks lets you mark and annotate locations in a file. Like if you were trying to understand some code and wanted to leave yourself notes but didn't want them in the file. I usually use todo comments, so I haven't actually tried this plugin.

I made a plugin that adds GoogleDocs-style comments to Neovim. Basically, you can highlight a specific region of text and add an annotation to it. You can retrieve the annotation for an annotated text region by placing the cursor in that region and executing the GetComment command. This plugin is mainly intended for prose, where lines (paragraphs) are relatively long and annotating specific parts of a line is useful. If you only need to annotate on a per-line basis, then a plugin like vim-bookmarks may work just as well or better.

So "Plan B" is now to experiment with vim-bookmarks. Bonus: there's a Telescope extension.

From what I've seen, people can only remember a few marks anyway, so having more wouldn't really help. If you really need more marks there are plugins like vim-bookmarks.

vim-bookmarks is a great plugin that simplifies dealing with marks yourself.

Have you considered using vim-bookmarks? It allows you to cycle through bookmarks among other features.