An opinionated view of the Tidyverse "dialect" of the R language. (by matloff)

TidyverseSkeptic Alternatives

Similar projects and alternatives to TidyverseSkeptic

NOTE: The number of mentions on this list indicates mentions on common posts plus user suggested alternatives. Hence, a higher number means a better TidyverseSkeptic alternative or higher similarity.

TidyverseSkeptic discussion

Log in or Post with

TidyverseSkeptic reviews and mentions

Posts with mentions or reviews of TidyverseSkeptic. We have used some of these posts to build our list of alternatives and similar projects. The last one was on 2024-02-23.
  • Why Pandas feels clunky when coming from R
    2 projects | news.ycombinator.com | 23 Feb 2024
    I just don't get these to be honest -- besides the fact that author missed simple things like `df.groupby('var',as_index=False)`, isn't this obviously arbitrary "this is easier my way" complaints? (I did R before all the chaining stuff was popular, and I wouldn't stuff everything into a single command like that even now. It isn't like you get lazy evaluation or any special data processing magic.)

    So I get people love chaining and tidyverse, good for you, I don't. But at least I can acknowledge that my way (or this way) people have different preferences and one is not intrinsically easier.

    Norm Matloff has a blog where he essentially just argues the opposite of all the tidyverse stuff, https://github.com/matloff/TidyverseSkeptic, but it is the same idea in reverse to me (one is not obviously easier to learn than the other IMO).

  • Where to learn R?
    5 projects | /r/math | 7 May 2023
    On the other hand, there is also a more traditional universe outside of the of the newer tidyverse approach. See the criticism of the tidyverse ecosystem by Prof Norm Matloff (of UC Davis). He provides a freely available introductory course in base R.
  • I will take that odds
    1 project | /r/ProgrammerHumor | 31 Mar 2023
    Whenever I hear tidyverse, I just feel the need to leave this: TidyverseSceptic
  • Base-R Is Alive and Well
    1 project | /r/rstats | 7 Aug 2022
    Yeah, I had never heard of him before, but I followed the link in the article above to his GitHub page and think he made some really great points about conciseness and clarity in base R code, and, I admittedly had no idea tapply() was so useful and easy to use, because I almost never see it used in any examples online. Although I agree with others here that he's misrepresenting why package developers use base R (which is to avoid dependences in their packages, which is very important), I also find myself agreeing with him that future R programmers not being taught base R is worrisome (I'm thinking of dependencies in future package development).
  • Your thoughts on base R? I never considered it and, after reading seemingly know little about it.
    1 project | /r/rprogramming | 11 Jul 2022
    I was in an R group meeting. One of the members mentioned Prof. Norm Matloff and said he has comments about tidyverse. I searched and found Matloff's explanation here. What are your thoughts on tidyverse and Matloff's comments about it? As I read it, I found myself agreeing with certain points. I do not have a computer science background; I'm someone trying to learn coding because I see uses for it in my work. I started my learning, about a year ago, with tidyverse tutorials. My patchwork jumping around, maybe in addition to some of the gaps Matloff indicates, show me that I know very little about base R.
  • In charge of making the transition from Excel to R at the office
    1 project | /r/rstats | 16 Jun 2022
    There are good arguments against tidyverse, especially for beginners. It doesn't lead to a growth in understanding the language fundamentals and requires to learn many functions, paradigms, and syntaxes not shared by base R, which can easily be overwhelming and lead to a learn-by-heart approach more than to a learn-by-understanding. There are many good articles on the topic, such as this one or a more in-depth one, suggesting to consider tidyverse a more advanced application for specific use cases, if you like the dialect. I don't, so I might be biased.
  • Teaching R in a Kinder, Gentler, More Effective Manner
    1 project | news.ycombinator.com | 13 May 2022
  • An opinionated view of the Tidyverse “dialect” of the R language
    1 project | news.ycombinator.com | 4 Apr 2022
  • Thoughts on book?
    1 project | /r/rstats | 5 Mar 2022
    I would discourage you to get into the tidyverse, at least in the first stages of your R training. It's like trying to learn english AND scottish together as a foreigner. You can read some better worded discussions here https://github.com/matloff/TidyverseSkeptic and here https://towardsdatascience.com/a-thousand-gadgets-my-thoughts-on-the-r-tidyverse-2441d8504433?gi=1b0a3648b6e6
  • Ho everyone I am R beginer. I need to to change the data type of these two columns, I tried as many ways I could find on the internet but it just won't work for me. This is really frustrating especially when you are a beginer, can you pleae provide a solution ? Thanks a lot in advance !
    1 project | /r/Rlanguage | 19 Jul 2021
    My opinions are largely in agreement with Norm Matloff on the subject actually.
  • A note from our sponsor - SaaSHub
    www.saashub.com | 24 Jun 2024
    SaaSHub helps you find the best software and product alternatives Learn more →


Basic TidyverseSkeptic repo stats
6 months ago

Power Real-Time Data Analytics at Scale
Get real-time insights from all types of time series data with InfluxDB. Ingest, query, and analyze billions of data points in real-time with unbounded cardinality.