FaaS in Go with WASM, WASI and Rust

• wuffs

  80 3,736 9.4 C

  Wrangling Untrusted File Formats Safely

  

Here's an off-topic answer.

Depends on what you want your toy language to do and what sort of runtime support you'd like to lean on.

JVM is pretty good for a lot of script-y languages, does impose overhead of having a JVM around. Provides GC, Threads, Reflection, consistent semantics. Tons of tools, libraries, support.

WebAssembly is constrained (for running-in-a-browser safety reasons) but then you get to run your code in a browser, or as a service, etc, and Other People are working hard on the problem of getting your WA to go fast. That used to be a big reason for using JVM, but it turns out that Security Is Darn Hard.

I have used C in the (distant) past as an IL, and that works up to a point, implementing garbage collection can be a pain if that's a thing that you want. C compilers have had a lot of work on them over the years, and you also have access to some low-level stuff, so if you were E.G. trying to come up with a little language that had super-good performance, C might be a good choice. (See also, [Wuffs](https://github.com/google/wuffs), by Nigel Tao et al at Google).

A suggestion, if you do target C -- don't work too hard to find isomorphisms between C's data structures and YourToyLang's data structures. Back around 1990, I did my C-generating compiler for Modula-3, and a friend at Xerox PARC used C as a target for Cedar Mesa, and Hans used it in a lower-level way (so I was mapping between M-3 records and C structs, for example, Hans was not) and the lower-level way worked better -- i.e., I chose poorly. It worked, but lower-level worked better.

If you are targeting a higher-level language, Rust and Go both seem like interesting options to me. Both have the disadvantage that they are still changing slightly but you get interesting "services" from the underlying VM -- for Rust, the borrow checker, plus libraries, for Go, reflection, goroutines, and the GC, plus libraries.

Rust should get you slightly higher performance, but I'd worry that you couldn't hide the existence of the borrow checker from your toy language, especially if you wanted to interact with Rust libraries from YTL. If you wanted to learn something vaguely publishable/wider-interesting, that question right there ("can I compile a TL to Rust, touch the Rust libraries, and not expose the borrow checker? No+what-I-tried/Yes+this-worked") is not bad.

I have a minor conflict of interest suggesting Go; I work on Go, usually on the compiler, and machine-generated code makes great test data. But regarded as a VM, I am a little puzzled why it hasn't seen wider use, because the GC is great (for lower-allocation rates than Java however; JVM GC has higher throughout efficiency, but Go has tagless objects, interior pointer support, and tiny pause times. Go-the-language makes it pretty easy to allocate less.) Things Go-as-a-VM currently lacks:

- tail call elimination (JVM same)

• go-pdfium-wasm

  1 5 10.0 Go

• WorkOS

  workos.com sponsored

  The modern identity platform for B2B SaaS. The APIs are flexible and easy-to-use, supporting authentication, user identity, and complex enterprise features like SSO and SCIM provisioning.

  

• go-sqlite3

  21 250 9.5 Go

  Go bindings to SQLite using wazero (by ncruces)

* https://github.com/ncruces/go-sqlite3

More here: https://wazero.io/community/users/

Note that often times a lot of work is porting because not all tools build well to wasm. This would apply for any runtime as we're just running the standard with some special extensions for emscripten, wasi etc.

• extism

  46 3,728 9.2 Rust

  The framework for building with WebAssembly (wasm). Easily load wasm modules, move data, call functions, and build extensible apps.

  

We’re trying to get close to this, via our Universal Plugin System, Extism: https://github.com/extism/extism

Call common wasm code across 16 different programming languages using our SDKs.

• webassembly-language-runtimes

  6 312 8.2 Shell

  Wasm Language Runtimes provides popular language runtimes (Ruby, Python, …) precompiled to WebAssembly that are tested for compatibility and kept up to date when new versions of upstream languages are released

  

Hello salaboy

Of course getting and gems etc gets weird in wasm..

Anyway, thanks to VMware labs for publishing interpreter wasm builds, people can play around. https://github.com/vmware-labs/webassembly-language-runtimes...

Random, but enjoy.

• InfluxDB

  www.influxdata.com sponsored

  Power Real-Time Data Analytics at Scale. Get real-time insights from all types of time series data with InfluxDB. Ingest, query, and analyze billions of data points in real-time with unbounded cardinality.

  

Suggest a related project