Our great sponsors
-
WorkOS
The modern identity platform for B2B SaaS. The APIs are flexible and easy-to-use, supporting authentication, user identity, and complex enterprise features like SSO and SCIM provisioning.
The historical reason is https://github.com/torvalds/linux/pull/17#issuecomment-56546...
Perhaps some of these issues have been fixed by now, but the Linux project has been going on just fine without GitHub (git was even invented for the Linux kernel project itself even before GitHub existed) so there doesn't seem to be any reason to switch even if all the mentioned problems were to be fixed
GitHub itself uses the OSI definition in its Readme guide to open source:
> Many people think that Open Source simply means availability of the source code of a project, but that does only tell part of the whole story.
> The Open Source Initiative (OSI) provides a commonly accepted definition of what constitutes Open Source. To summarize that, in order to be constituted Open Source,
>> a work has to allow free redistribution,
>> the source code needs to be made available,
>> it must be possible to create further works based on it,
>> there must be no limitations of who may use the work or for what purpose (so something like "no commercial use" or "no military use" won't fly with Open Source),
>> the work must not require an additional license on top of the one it comes with,
>> and finally, the license must not depend on a specific distribution format, technology or presence of other works.
> So, you see, it goes way beyond "the source code is available", in fact, a whole lot more requirements are stated that must be fulfilled in order for a work to really be considered Open Source.
https://github.com/readme/guides/open-source-licensing
Also, GitHub's most starred repo is freeCodeCamp (359k stars - https://github.com/freeCodeCamp/freeCodeCamp). Linked right in the repo, freeCodeCamp defines open source as:
> Open Source Software is code that is publicly available for people to view, modify, and share.
https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/what-is-open-source-softwa...
GitHub itself uses the OSI definition in its Readme guide to open source:
> Many people think that Open Source simply means availability of the source code of a project, but that does only tell part of the whole story.
> The Open Source Initiative (OSI) provides a commonly accepted definition of what constitutes Open Source. To summarize that, in order to be constituted Open Source,
>> a work has to allow free redistribution,
>> the source code needs to be made available,
>> it must be possible to create further works based on it,
>> there must be no limitations of who may use the work or for what purpose (so something like "no commercial use" or "no military use" won't fly with Open Source),
>> the work must not require an additional license on top of the one it comes with,
>> and finally, the license must not depend on a specific distribution format, technology or presence of other works.
> So, you see, it goes way beyond "the source code is available", in fact, a whole lot more requirements are stated that must be fulfilled in order for a work to really be considered Open Source.
https://github.com/readme/guides/open-source-licensing
Also, GitHub's most starred repo is freeCodeCamp (359k stars - https://github.com/freeCodeCamp/freeCodeCamp). Linked right in the repo, freeCodeCamp defines open source as:
> Open Source Software is code that is publicly available for people to view, modify, and share.
https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/what-is-open-source-softwa...
Related posts
- Codepen, React and Front End Development Libraries Projects
- How Open Source helped me get into the GitHub Octernships program.
- Aspiring web developer; about to lose wifi for a long period. How can I spend my time learning without internet (much) access?
- Stuck at Exercise Tracker
- Calculator tests failing (but work when entered manually)