erg VS pytype

Looking through the code, Pylyzer seems to be a thin wrapper around Erg [1]. To typecheck, it converts your Python AST to an Erg AST, then runs its through the Erg typechecker and returns the errors.

Faster typechecking for Python is very much needed. But this project seems like it was built in a hackathon —- it is not a true standalone typchecker.

[1] https://github.com/erg-lang/erg

erg – A Python-compatible statically typed language

https://github.com/erg-lang/erg/blob/726b7b80fcf06c6c4099b62...

Using a 69 as your language's logo? I actually don't think it has been done in a serious-seeming project before.

For someone stuck at this issue. This was fixed in latest version : https://github.com/erg-lang/erg/issues/8

Dont do cargo install erg , but rather build from source and this works.

Pytype checks and infers types for your Python code - without requiring type annotations. Pytype can catch type errors in your Python code before you even run it.

Pyre from Meta, pyright from Microsoft and PyType from Google provide additional assistance. They can 'infer' types based on code flow and existing types within the code.

we've written a little bit about what pytype does differently here: https://google.github.io/pytype/

our main focus is to be able to work with unannotated and partially-annotated code, and treat it on par with fully annotated code.

What is the smart money doing for type checking in Python? I've used mypy which seems to work well but is incredibly slow (3-4s to update linting after I change code). I've tried pylance type checking in VS Code, which seems to work well + fast but is less clear and comprehensive than mypy. I've also seen projects like pytype [1] and pyre [2] used by Google/Meta, but people say those tools don't really make sense to use unless you're an engineer for those companies.

Am just curious if mypy is really the best option right now?

[1] https://github.com/google/pytype

Check out https://github.com/google/pytype

i work on https://github.com/google/pytype which is largely developed internally and then pushed to github every few days. the github commits are associated with the team's personal github accounts. pytype is not an "official google product" insofar as the open source version is presented as is without official google support, but it is "production code" in the sense that it is very much used extensively within google.

pytype dev here - thanks for the kind words :) whole-program analysis on unannotated or partially-annotated code is our particular focus, but there's surprisingly little dark PLT magic involved; in particular you don't need to be an academic type theory wizard to understand how it works. our developer docs[1] have more info, but at a high level we have an interpreter that virtually executes python bytecode, tracking types where the cpython interpreter would have tracked values.

it's worth exploring some of the other type checkers as well, since they make different tradeoffs - in particular, microsoft's pyright[2] (written in typescript!) can run incrementally within vscode, and tends to add new and experimentally proposed typing PEPs faster than we do.

[1] https://github.com/google/pytype/blob/main/docs/developers/i...

another library to check typing in python code (by google)

The main ones I can think about are: * mypy * pytype * pyright