durexforth VS stoneknifeforth

Compare durexforth vs stoneknifeforth and see what are their differences.


Modern C64 Forth (by jkotlinski)


a tiny self-hosted Forth implementation (by kragen)
Our great sponsors
  • SonarQube - Static code analysis for 29 languages.
  • InfluxDB - Access the most powerful time series database as a service
  • SaaSHub - Software Alternatives and Reviews
durexforth stoneknifeforth
5 10
201 390
- -
8.3 0.0
8 days ago about 3 years ago
Forth Forth
GNU General Public License v3.0 or later Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives.
Stars - the number of stars that a project has on GitHub. Growth - month over month growth in stars.
Activity is a relative number indicating how actively a project is being developed. Recent commits have higher weight than older ones.
For example, an activity of 9.0 indicates that a project is amongst the top 10% of the most actively developed projects that we are tracking.


Posts with mentions or reviews of durexforth. We have used some of these posts to build our list of alternatives and similar projects. The last one was on 2021-02-17.


Posts with mentions or reviews of stoneknifeforth. We have used some of these posts to build our list of alternatives and similar projects. The last one was on 2022-10-18.
  • Stop Writing Dead Programs (Transcript)
    7 projects | news.ycombinator.com | 18 Oct 2022
    I've done all these things (except designing the hardware) and I agree that it can be very painful. I did some of them in 02008, for example: https://github.com/kragen/stoneknifeforth

    The thing is, though, you can also not do all those things. You can use variables, and they don't even have to be allocated on a stack (unless you're writing a recursive function, which you usually aren't), and all the NIP TUCK ROT goes away, and with it all the Memory Championship tricks. You can test each definition interactively as you write it, and then the fact that the language is absurdly error-prone hardly matters. You can use metaprogramming so that your code is as DRY as a nun's pochola. You can use the interactivity of Forth to quickly validate your hypotheses about not just your code but also the hardware in a way you can't do with C. You can do it with GDB, but Forth is a lot faster than GDBscript, but that's not saying much because even Bash is a lot faster than GDBscript.

    But Yossi was just using Forth as a programming language, like a C without local variables or type checking, not an embedded operating system. And, as I said, that's really not Forth's strength. Bash and Tcl aren't good programming languages, either. If you try to use Tcl as a substitute for C you will also be very sad. But the way they're used, that isn't that important.

    I explained a more limited version of this 12 years ago: https://yosefk.com/blog/my-history-with-forth-stack-machines...

    So, I don't think Forth is only useful when you have the freedom to change the problem, though programs in any language do become an awful lot easier when you have that freedom.

  • StoneKnifeForth
    5 projects | news.ycombinator.com | 17 Jul 2022
  • A complete compiler and VM in 150 lines of code
    4 projects | news.ycombinator.com | 16 Jul 2022
    That's powerful enough to conveniently write, for example, a numerical root finding program for an arbitrary arithmetic expression.

    But I think that within a complexity budget of 150 lines of code you can maybe be even more ambitious than that.

    The example compiler in https://github.com/darius/parson/blob/master/eg_calc_compile... is a bit more stripped down than that, but in its 32 lines of code it compiles arithmetic assignment statements to a three-address RISC-like code (though using an unbounded number of registers). https://github.com/darius/parson/blob/master/eg_calc_to_rpn.... is a 16-line version that compiles the same language to a stack machine like your tutorial example.

    In 66 lines of code in https://github.com/kragen/peg-bootstrap/blob/master/peg.md I wrote an example compiler which compiles a PEG grammar into a JavaScript parser for that grammar. Admittedly those 66 lines do not include an implementation of JavaScript to run the code on. It compiles the language it's written in.

    In 132 lines of code in https://github.com/kragen/stoneknifeforth/blob/master/tinybo... I wrote an example compiler which compiles a crippled Forth dialect into i386 machine code, including an ELF header so you can run the result. It also compiles the language it's written in. It also doesn't include an i386 emulator to run it on.

    In 83 lines of code in http://canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/neelcompiler.ml Neel Krishnaswami wrote a compiler from the untyped λ-calculus to a simple assembly language for a register machine. It also doesn't include an implementation of the assembly language.

    In 18 lines of code in http://canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/meta5ix.m5, a simplification of META-II, I wrote a compiler from grammar descriptions to an assembly code for a parsing-oriented virtual machine. It compiles the language it's written in. A Python interpreter for the machine is in http://canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/meta5ixrun.py (109 lines of code) and a precompiled version of the compiler-compiler for bootstrapping is in http://canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/meta5ix.generated.m5asm.

    A slightly incompatible variant of Meta5ix which instead compiles itself to C is in http://canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/meta5ix2c.m5 (133 lines of code, depending on how you count). (No C compiler is included.) The precompiled C output for bootstrapping is in http://canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/meta5ix2c.c.

    Meta5ix is extremely weak and limited, really only enough for a compiler front-end; it can't, for example, do the kinds of RPN tricks we're talking about above.

  • Looking for a simple forth compiler (producing asm/executables, not compiling forth words) to learn from, preferably in C family language
    5 projects | /r/Forth | 7 Aug 2021
    Title effectively says it all. The only thing I have found is StoneKnife Forth (implementation is in tinyboot1.tbf1) but this file is implemented in the same dialect of forth it implements, which due to being minimal makes it difficult to read and comprehend efficiently (I also can't find the origin of some words such as 'byte' used in the code but not implemented by the interpreter). I would prefer something in the C family to look at but anything should do as long as it's clean enough that I could use it as a reference to reimplement the compiler without much difficulty. Thank you in advance for any help with what is seemingly quite a narrow request.
  • An HTTP server in a single .c file
    12 projects | news.ycombinator.com | 2 Apr 2021
    I'm pretty sure Linux ELF has always allowed you to specify the initial load address. When I first wrote StoneKnifeForth https://github.com/kragen/stoneknifeforth its load address was 0x1000, but at some point Linux stopped allowing load addresses lower than 0x10000 by default (vm.mmap_min_addr). I originally wrote it in 02008, using the lower load address, and fixed it in 02017. It's still not using 0x804800 like normal executables but 0x20000. ASLR does not affect this.

    Maybe you mean that before ELF support, Linux a.out executables had to be loaded at a fixed virtual address? That's possible—I started using Linux daily in 01995, at which point a.out was already only supported for backward compatibility.

  • StoneKnifeForth (With a Metacircular Compiler)
    6 projects | news.ycombinator.com | 18 Feb 2021
  • RetroForth 2021.1 Is Released
    6 projects | news.ycombinator.com | 17 Feb 2021

What are some alternatives?

When comparing durexforth and stoneknifeforth you can also consider the following projects:

zeptoforth - A not-so-small Forth for Cortex-M

jonesforth - Mirror of JONESFORTH

factor - Factor programming language

subleq - 16-bit SUBLEQ CPU running eForth - just for fun

elfort - A Forth metacompiler that directly emits an executable binary for x86-64 Linux written in Arkam

swapforth - Swapforth is a cross-platform ANS Forth

r4 - :r4 concatenative programming language with ideas from ColorForth.

r3d4 - r3 programing language for 64 bits Windows/Linux/Mac/Rasberry Pi 4

http - A simple multi-threaded HTTP/1.0-ish file server. Single file, ~250 LOC.

darkhttpd - When you need a web server in a hurry.