cleverhans VS captum

I only knew of this story from looking up the name of this library on adversarial DL https://github.com/cleverhans-lab/cleverhans

I feel as though this area has not received much attention over the last couple of years. The CleverHans project has gone stale and I haven't heard of many new results recently. Has the community lost interest in this area? Did we decide that adversarial attacks aren't such a problem in practical applications?

Most likely, NNs in general love shortcut learning (see Geirhos et al. 2020). In general, local explanations such as grad-cam are quite noisy, and sometimes even inconsistent (see Seo et al. 2018 ). Now, in my experience, I've seen that integrated gradients (see Sundararajan et al 2017) does a better job compared to Grad-CAM (also, add a noise tunnel), but this is only based on my limited experience. I would totally recommend using the implementations from the Captum library for loca explanations.

Take a look at captum

Sometimes. If explainable predictions are part of your business requirements, it's probably better not to rely entirely on black box models and instead design a system that gives you the information you need as part of it. If you end up using black box models, there are still methods that attempt to help attribute explanations to your prediction. Here's an example of a toolkit for attributing explanations post-hoc to black box model predictions: https://github.com/pytorch/captum

The straightforward way to interpret RL agent's decision is to use captum library.

My use-case is research-oriented. I work on Explainable AI. Generally, the best package I've come across to compute attributions in Pytorch Captum. If your object detector is in PyTorch, you can perhaps build it in.

Do any JAX experts know if there is an equivalent to https://captum.ai/ - a model interpretability library for pytorch?

In particular i want to be able to measure feature importance on both inputs and internal layers on a sample by sample basis. This is the only thing currently holding me back from using JAX right now.

Alternatively a simle to read/understand/port implementation of DeepLIFT would work too.

thanks

I'm interested to use JAX but am having a hard time finding anything similar to captum for the pytorch world.

Do you actually want to implement something? There are decent explainability libraries now, e.g., [AIX360](https://aix360.mybluemix.net/), [InterpretML](https://interpret.ml/), or [captum](https://captum.ai/). Pytorch + maybe pytorch lightning + captum might be the quickest way to actually implement something like an explainable neural net yourself. Do the standard tutorials for each of them and watch a few YT videos (or follow a coursera course or something like that) about how these things work in theory and practice, and you'll get up to speed relatively quickly. You will not be able to do useful work in ML without actually learning the ropes.