BeanstalkD VS dramatiq

There's beanstalkd, it has a few Python libraries and it works out of the box with ActiveJob via Backburner.

https://beanstalkd.github.io/

Messaging/Queueing Systems (Amazon SQS, RabbitMQ, Beanstalkd)

Not when a queue is involved. IME trying to replicate something like beanstalkd (https://beanstalkd.github.io/) in postgres is asking for trouble for anything but trivial workloads.

If you're measuring throughput in jobs/s, use a real work queue.

Before Kafka was a standard, I created a go library for beanstalkd that act like an RPC.

Then there are queue libraries like beanstalkd, RabbitMQ or built-in features like queues from Laravel. These will probably get you quicker to your goal then trying the process managing route.

The only task queue I loved was beanstalkd -- it's beautifully written and highly performant. Starting it takes seconds and it's been running for a decade:

https://beanstalkd.github.io/

It's not rust (it's C), but beanstalkd is a pretty incredible work queue that processes millions of jobs a day (10K+/s at peak) for my company. I know there are a few rust drivers available.

Using something like Dramatiq [1] with Redis, writing a background job takes minutes, and can be deployed alongside an existing Python web app. There are probably JS equivalents.

I think Inngest could be a useful service, but the comparison felt off for me - it made me feel like this wasn't solving a real problem.

[1] https://dramatiq.io/

Dramatiq documentation

Hello everyone. We want to present you Taskiq: our new project that allows sending tasks using distributed queues. Conceptually it's similar to Celery or Dramatiq but with full asyncio and type hints support. Taskiq can send and execute async functions and has many integrations with different queue implementations.

I spent 3 years building a high scale crawler on top of Celery.

I can't recommend it. We found many bugs in the more advanced features of Celery (like Canvas) we also ran into some really weird issues like tasks getting duplicated for no reason [1].

The most concerning problem is that the project was abandoned. The original creator is not working on it anymore and all issues that we raised were ignored. We had to fork the project and apply our own fixes to it. This was 4 years ago so maybe things improved since them.

Celery is also extremely complex.

I would recommend https://dramatiq.io/ instead.

[1]: https://github.com/celery/celery/issues/4426

I have been using dramatiq lately (celery alternative) and so far I'm happy with it.

this is a more robust solution. https://dramatiq.io/

Dramatiq -> Just another celery?